Owe more than the house is worth?
That is called being underwater. Here are your real options. One honest point first: if there is no equity, a cash buyer like us usually cannot help unless your lender agrees to a short sale.
Free help first: New York's Homeowner Protection Program, 1-855-466-3456.
First, check the real numbers
A lot of people guess. Before you decide anything, get three numbers:
- What you owe. Ask your servicer for a payoff statement, not just the balance on your monthly bill. Add any home equity line, judgments and back taxes.
- What the house is worth as it sits. Online estimates can miss badly on older Buffalo houses. A local agent's opinion or an appraisal is better.
- What selling costs. If you list, there is commission, the New York transfer tax of 0.4 percent and your attorney. The full list of costs.
If the house is worth more than the payoff plus the selling costs, you have equity and you are not underwater. If not, the gap is what has to be solved before any sale can close.
| Example, round numbers for illustration only | Amount |
|---|---|
| What the house would sell for as-is | $110,000 |
| Mortgage payoff | $118,000 |
| Back taxes and a small judgment | $3,000 |
| Gap before any selling costs | $11,000 short |
In this example, no buyer can close at $110,000 unless the lender agrees to take less, or the seller brings $11,000 or more to closing.
Your options
| Option | How it works | Good to know |
|---|---|---|
| Keep paying | If the payment fits your budget, staying put pays the loan down over time. | Works only if you can afford it. No one can promise prices will rise. |
| Loan modification | The lender changes the loan terms, such as the rate, the length or the payment, so it is affordable. | You apply through your servicer. A free counselor can help with the paperwork. |
| Short sale | The lender agrees to let you sell for less than you owe and takes the sale money. | Needs the lender's written approval of the buyer and the price. It can take months. |
| Deed in lieu of foreclosure | You give the house to the lender instead of going through a foreclosure. | The lender has to agree, and it will look at the title and any other liens. |
| Sell for cash | A buyer pays, and the mortgage and liens are paid off at closing. | Works when there is enough equity. With no equity, it only works as a short sale. |
| Bankruptcy | A court process that can change what you owe or give you time. Selling during bankruptcy. | Talk to a bankruptcy attorney first. |
Already behind on payments? Start here. Already served with foreclosure papers? Read this.
How a short sale works
- Call your servicer and ask how it handles short sales. A free counselor can make this call with you.
- The lender asks for financial papers that show why you cannot keep paying.
- You get a signed offer from a buyer and send it to the lender.
- The lender checks the value of the house and decides whether to accept the price.
- If it agrees, you get an approval letter with the price, the closing deadline and what the lender will accept. Read it with your attorney.
- At closing, the lender gets the sale money. A second mortgage or other lienholders also have to agree to release their liens.
Two questions to ask before any short sale
What happens to the rest of the debt? After a foreclosure sale, a New York lender can ask the court for a judgment for the difference, and you may be able to contest it. In a short sale, ask the lender to say in writing that the sale settles the debt in full, and have your attorney read the approval letter before you sign anything.
Will I owe tax on the forgiven part? The IRS treats canceled debt as taxable income unless an exclusion applies. The special exclusion for a main home covers debt discharged before January 1, 2026, or under a written arrangement made before then. Other exclusions, such as being insolvent, may still apply. The lender may send you a Form 1099-C. Ask a tax professional before you agree.
When a cash sale works, and when it does not
We buy houses as-is. Our offer starts from what the house would sell for fixed up, minus the repairs and our costs, so it is usually below full retail. That has a plain result:
- If you have equity, a cash sale can pay off the mortgage and liens at closing. You keep what is left, we pay the closing costs, and there is no commission.
- If you are underwater, our offer will usually be less than you owe. Then the sale only works if your lender approves a short sale at our price. A lender is often more likely to approve a higher offer, and listing with an agent may bring one. If that is your best route, we will say so.
We will run the numbers with you either way. The honest comparison of cash and listing.
Free help, and what to avoid
- Homeowner Protection Program: New York's free housing counseling and legal services for homeowners. Call 1-855-466-3456 or visit homeownerhelpny.org.
- Find a HUD-approved counselor: use the federal housing counselor search by ZIP code. Help is often free or low cost.
- Never pay upfront. Federal rules make it illegal for most companies to charge you before you have a written offer of relief from your lender and accept it. New York bars distressed property consultants from taking any payment before their services are fully done.
- Never sign your deed over to someone who promises to fix the loan. Giving away the deed does not get rid of the mortgage.
Sources: NY Attorney General, Homeowner Protection Program; HomeownerHelpNY; NY DFS, Foreclosure Bill of Rights; IRS Topic 431, Canceled Debt (updated 2026); CFPB, find a housing counselor; FTC, Mortgage Relief Scams; Real Property Law 265-b; Tax Law 1402; CPLR 3408. General information, not legal or tax advice. Your own attorney can tell you what applies to you.
Questions people ask
Can I sell my house if I owe more than it is worth?
Yes, but only if the lender agrees to take less than it is owed, which is called a short sale, or if you pay the difference at closing. Every mortgage and lien has to be paid or released for the buyer to get clear title.
Will a cash buyer pay off my whole mortgage?
Only if the house is worth enough. A cash offer is usually below full retail, so if you are underwater it usually will not cover the payoff. We will tell you that up front.
Is forgiven mortgage debt taxable?
It can be. The IRS treats canceled debt as income unless an exclusion applies. The IRS says the special exclusion for a main home covers debt discharged before January 1, 2026, or under a written arrangement made before then. Other exclusions, such as insolvency, may apply. Ask a tax professional.
Who can help me talk to my lender for free?
New York's Homeowner Protection Program at 1-855-466-3456 connects homeowners with free housing counselors and legal services.
Other situations we help with
Get a cash offer
Takes 30 seconds. We call you back the same day during business hours, and you get a written offer within 24 hours of the walkthrough. No obligation.
By sending this form you agree Spiti Buyers may text or call you about your house. Message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out.
Want the real numbers?
Text us the address and what you owe. If a cash sale will not work, we will tell you.
Text (716) 468-2932 Or call