Behind on property taxes?
Who you owe depends on where the house is. Here is how tax foreclosure works around Buffalo, in plain words, and who to call first.
Call the tax office first. If selling makes sense after that, call us.
Who collects the back taxes
| Where the house is | Who handles delinquent taxes |
|---|---|
| City of Buffalo | City of Buffalo tax office, (716) 851-5734. Buffalo's foreclosure can include unpaid water, sewer and garbage user fee bills, not just taxes. |
| City of Lackawanna | City of Lackawanna tax collector, (716) 827-6471. |
| City of Tonawanda | City of Tonawanda treasurer, (716) 695-8637. |
| Towns and villages in Erie County | Erie County Real Property Tax Services, (716) 858-8333. Payoffs are online at paytax.erie.gov. |
| Niagara County | Start with your city or town tax collector. They will tell you which office has the delinquent taxes. |
Phone numbers are from Erie County's 2026 tax foreclosure notice. Call to confirm before you pay.
How tax foreclosure works here
- Unpaid taxes become a lien on the house and keep growing with interest and penalties.
- Erie County can start foreclosure once county tax liens have gone unpaid for two years or more. It files a list of the properties and mails notices to the owners.
- The notice gives a last day to redeem. Pay the back taxes and fees by then and the house comes off the list. In the 2026 county foreclosure, that included a $500 foreclosure fee on top of the taxes.
- If it is not redeemed, the court orders the house sold at a public auction.
- The City of Buffalo runs its own separate foreclosure for Buffalo houses, usually with an auction in the fall.
Before you do anything else
- Call the tax office for an exact payoff and ask whether you qualify for a payment plan.
- Call New York's Homeowner Protection Program at 1-855-466-3456 for free counseling and legal help.
- Check your exemptions. Seniors, veterans and people with disabilities can qualify for lower taxes.
- Never pay anyone an upfront fee to stop a tax foreclosure.
When selling makes sense
If the taxes are more than you can catch up on, selling before the last day to redeem keeps the price and the closing date in your hands. After a tax foreclosure, the auction sets the price, and getting back any leftover money means filing a claim and waiting. The back taxes are paid from the sale at closing. Behind on the mortgage too? Read this first.
Questions people ask
Can I sell a house that is in tax foreclosure?
Usually yes, until the last day to redeem passes. The back taxes and fees are paid from the sale at closing. Title work takes time, so call early, not the week of the deadline.
How are the back taxes paid if I sell?
From the sale price at closing, the same way a mortgage is paid off. Our written offer shows the numbers.
Is there help paying my property taxes?
Ask the tax office about payment plans. If you are 65 or older, a veteran, or have a disability, ask your town or city assessor whether you get every exemption you qualify for. New York's Homeowner Protection Program (1-855-466-3456) offers free counseling.
What if I let it go to auction?
You lose control of the sale and the price. Selling first lets you set the terms and keep what is left after the taxes are paid.
Other situations we help with
Get a cash offer
Takes 30 seconds. We call you back the same day during business hours, and you get a written offer within 24 hours of the walkthrough. No obligation.
By sending this form you agree Spiti Buyers may text or call you about your house. Message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out.
Running out of time?
Text or call. If paying the taxes and keeping the house is possible, we will tell you to do that.
Text (716) 468-2932 Or call