Squatters in a Buffalo house: what New York law says now
Since 2024, New York law says a squatter is not a tenant. Here is what that means for an empty Buffalo house, and what to do first.
Texting is fastest. We answer texts and calls 8 AM to 8 PM, 7 days a week. After hours, text us and we get back to you the next morning.
The short answer
In April 2024, as part of the state budget, New York added language to section 711 of the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law (RPAPL) saying that "a tenant shall not include a squatter." The law defines a squatter as a person who enters or intrudes on property without the permission of the person entitled to possession, and keeps occupying it without title, right or permission.
Before the change, a lot of owners believed anyone who stayed 30 days got tenant rights. The lawmakers who wrote the language said it makes clear that squatters are not tenants and do not get tenant protections after 30 days.
If you find someone in your house who never had permission to be there, call the police. If the person claims a lease or permission, the dispute may have to go to court. In the City of Buffalo, that is Buffalo City Court.
Squatter, tenant, holdover or guest?
| Who is in the house | What the law says |
|---|---|
| Squatter | Came in without anyone's permission and stays without any right. Not a tenant under section 711. If it goes to court, the owner can bring a case after a 10-day notice to quit (section 713, subdivision 3). |
| Tenant | Has a lease or pays rent. Section 711 says no tenant or lawful occupant of a home can be removed except in a court proceeding. For unpaid rent, the case starts with a written 14-day rent demand. |
| Holdover | A tenant who stays after the lease ends without the landlord's permission. A court case under section 711, subdivision 1. |
| Licensee | Someone the owner let live there without a lease, like a relative or a friend. After the permission ends and a 10-day notice to quit, a court case under section 713, subdivision 7. |
Inherited houses: who is actually living there?
When an owner dies, the person in the house is often not a stranger. It may be a relative who lived with the owner, a friend who was watching the place, or a tenant with a lease. Those people usually had permission, so they are not squatters under the new definition, and removing them usually takes the court process for licensees or tenants.
A true squatter is someone who broke in or moved in after the house went empty, with no one's permission. Keep proof of when the house was last empty and locked: dated photos, utility records, a neighbor who checks on it. That proof helps if the person later says they had permission.
If the owner died, the estate's executor or administrator is usually the one who can act for the house. Talk to the estate attorney. How probate works in Erie County.
Do not try to force anyone out yourself
Do not change the locks on someone living there, shut off the heat or water, or move their things out on your own. Section 711 says a lawful occupant can only be removed in a court proceeding, and if you guess wrong about who counts as lawful, you can end up being the one in trouble. Let the police and the court do it, and talk to an attorney first.
Steps to protect an empty house
- Visit often, or have someone you trust check it every week. In winter, check the heat.
- Lock every door and window, and board any broken ones. Change the locks once you have the right to, for example after an executor is appointed.
- Call your insurance company. Many homeowner policies limit coverage when a house sits empty. Read the vacancy part of yours and ask about a vacant house policy.
- Keep the heat on, or have the house winterized. A burst pipe can do more damage than a squatter.
- Do not let mail and flyers pile up on the porch.
- Give a neighbor your number, and take dated photos of every room.
Where the case goes in Buffalo
Court cases to get a house back in the city go to Buffalo City Court, which has a housing and landlord tenant part. The court is at 50 Delaware Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14202, and its main number is (716) 845-2600. Outside the city, cases go to the local city, town or village court.
For free legal help if you have a low income, call the Erie County Bar Association Volunteer Lawyers Project at (716) 847-0662. For a private attorney, the Bar Association of Erie County's Lawyer Referral Service, (716) 852-3100, sets up a 30-minute consultation for $20.
Where a cash sale fits (and where it doesn't)
It can fit when you live out of town, the house keeps getting broken into, someone is living there, and you do not want to manage a court case and then the repairs. You can sell a house with people in it. We will look at it, and the contract spells out who is living there, who handles getting the house empty, and how that affects the price. We pay the closing costs, and you pay your own attorney.
It may not fit when the person is likely to leave soon and the house is in good shape. An empty, clean house brings more money, from us or from anyone. If you can wait, waiting may pay. See the honest comparison.
Sources: RPAPL 711; RPAPL 713; NY Senate press release on the squatter definition (April 22, 2024); NY Courts, Buffalo City Court; Erie County Bar Association Volunteer Lawyers Project; Bar Association of Erie County Lawyer Referral and Information Service. General information, not legal or tax advice.
Questions people ask
Does a squatter get tenant rights after 30 days in New York?
Not anymore. Since April 2024, RPAPL section 711 says a tenant does not include a squatter, meaning someone who entered without permission and stays without title, right or permission. The 30 day rule in that section is about people living in rooming houses and hotels.
Can the police remove a squatter in Buffalo?
The 2024 change means a squatter does not get tenant protections. What officers do depends on what they find. If the person shows a lease or claims they had permission, expect the case to go to Buffalo City Court.
Is a relative living in my late parent's house a squatter?
Usually not. Someone who moved in with the owner's permission is more like a licensee. Once the permission ends, New York law allows a court case after a 10-day notice to quit (RPAPL 713). Talk to the estate attorney first.
More plain guides
Get a cash offer
Takes 30 seconds. We call you back the same day during business hours, and you get a written offer within 24 hours of the walkthrough. No obligation.
By sending this form you agree Spiti Buyers may text or call you about your house. Message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out.
Someone in your empty house?
Text us the address and what is going on. We will tell you your options.
Text (716) 468-2932 Or call