Siblings who do not agree on the house
One wants to keep it, one wants to sell, one wants to rent it out. Here is how New York families settle it, from a kitchen table deal to a court case.
Texting is fastest. We answer texts and calls 8 AM to 8 PM, 7 days a week. After hours, text us and we get back to you the next morning.
The short answer
If you and your brothers or sisters inherit a house together and cannot agree, you have a few main paths: one of you buys out the others, you all agree to sell and split the money, you try mediation, or someone asks a court to divide or sell the house in a partition case. Court is the slowest and most expensive path. A buyout or an agreed sale usually costs the family far less. One clear, written number for the house often gets the talk moving.
First, is the house still in the estate?
Who owns the house right now changes the answer.
- Still in the estate. If probate is open, the executor or administrator manages the house. New York law generally gives that person the power to sell estate property unless the will or a court order limits it (EPTL 11-1.1). Every heir's signature is not always needed, but court letters can carry limits, so the estate attorney checks them first. An heir with concerns should talk to their own attorney.
- Already in your names. When property passes to two or more people, New York treats them as tenants in common unless the deed or will says joint tenancy (EPTL 6-2.2). Each of you owns a share, and selling the whole house usually takes everyone's signature or a court order.
If there was no will and no surviving spouse, the children inherit everything equally (EPTL 4-1.1). A will can split it differently. How probate works in Erie County.
Your options, from simplest to hardest
| Option | How it works | Good to know |
|---|---|---|
| Buyout | The sibling who wants the house pays the others for their shares, often with a mortgage in their own name. | Agree on a value first. An appraisal or a written offer gives you a starting point. |
| Sell together | Everyone signs, the house is sold, and the money is split by share after the mortgage, liens and costs. | Decide up front who picks the price and who looks after the house until closing. |
| Keep and rent | Keep the house, rent it out, and share the rent and the bills. | Works only if everyone trusts the person managing it. Put it in writing. |
| Mediation | A neutral person helps the family talk it through and write down an agreement. | Voluntary and confidential, and more cost-effective than a lawsuit. |
| Partition case | A co-owner asks a court to divide the property or order it sold (RPAPL Article 9). | The slowest and most expensive path. Each side usually pays its own lawyer. |
How a partition case works in New York
A co-owner can ask a court to split up property they own with others (RPAPL 901). A house cannot be cut in half, so the court can order it sold if dividing it would cause great prejudice to the owners. The money is then split by each owner's share.
Since December 6, 2019, New York has had extra rules for inherited family property, its version of the Uniform Partition of Heirs Property Act (RPAPL 993). It generally applies when there is no written agreement among the owners about partition, at least one owner got their share from a relative, the property is used as a home or a farm, and another test is met, such as relatives holding 20 percent or more of the shares. When it applies:
- The court first sets the value, by everyone's agreement or with an appraisal by an independent licensed appraiser.
- Owners who did not ask for a sale get the first chance to buy out the ones who did, at that value. They have 45 days after the notice of value to say so.
- Before ordering a sale, the court weighs things like how long the family has owned the house, sentimental attachment, and who paid the taxes, insurance and upkeep.
- If the house is sold, it is normally listed on the open market by a licensed broker at no less than the court-set value, rather than sold at auction.
These rules protect families, but they take time and money: lawyers, a valuation, hearings and a broker. Talk to a real estate or estate attorney before you start a partition case or answer one.
Try mediation first
In Western New York, the Community Mediation Center run by Child and Family Services is part of the state court system's network of Community Dispute Resolution Centers and works with courts in all eight counties of the region. Call (716) 362-2323 to ask about mediation and what it costs. A mediator does not pick a winner. The family makes the decision, and the mediator helps you get there.
How one written offer helps
A lot of family fights over a house are really fights over what it is worth. One sibling remembers the house at its best. Another sees the roof and the wet basement. A written number, with the repairs and costs shown, gives everyone the same starting point. It can become the buyout price, a floor for a listing, or just a reality check. Nobody has to accept it.
Where a cash sale fits (and where it doesn't)
It can fit when everyone agrees they want out, nobody wants to manage repairs or showings, and the house needs work. We make one written offer that every heir and every attorney can read. We buy as-is, contents and all, and we pay the closing costs. We are the buyer, not a mediator, so we stay out of who gets what.
It does not fit when one sibling truly wants the house and can pay a fair buyout. That keeps the house in the family. If the house is in good shape and the family can wait, listing it may bring more. If a partition case is already open, the court's process controls the sale, so talk to your attorney first. See also selling an inherited house.
Sources: RPAPL 901; RPAPL 993; Assembly bill A7058, signed December 6, 2019 (Chapter 596); EPTL 11-1.1; EPTL 6-2.2; EPTL 4-1.1; Child and Family Services, Community Mediation Center; Child and Family Services news release (June 2025). General information, not legal advice. Laws and rules change, so your attorney will confirm what applies to you.
Questions people ask
Can my sibling force a sale of our inherited house in New York?
A co-owner can ask a court for partition, and the court can order a sale if dividing the property would cause great prejudice to the owners. For inherited family property, New York's heirs property law adds steps first, including a court-set value and a chance for the other owners to buy out the one who asked for a sale.
Do all heirs have to agree to sell a house in an estate?
Not always. While the house is in the estate, the executor or administrator generally has the power to sell, unless the will or a court order limits it. Once the house is in the heirs' names, a sale of the whole house usually needs every owner or a court order.
How long does a partition case take?
There is no set time. It involves court papers, a valuation, hearings and often a broker sale, so it usually takes much longer and costs more than a buyout or a sale the family agrees on.
Is mediation binding?
Mediation is voluntary. If the family reaches an agreement, your attorneys can put it in writing as a binding contract.
More plain guides
Get a cash offer
Takes 30 seconds. We call you back the same day during business hours, and you get a written offer within 24 hours of the walkthrough. No obligation.
By sending this form you agree Spiti Buyers may text or call you about your house. Message and data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out.
One number the whole family can look at
No sides taken. Every heir gets the same information.
Text (716) 468-2932 Or call